← Back to all posts

From Freshwater to Reef: How Claude Desktop Helped Me Plan My Aquarium Conversion

Aug 30, 20256 min readBy Hawkes
Claude DesktopReal World AIResearchPlanning

The Challenge: Converting to Saltwater on a Budget

I had a 75-gallon freshwater aquarium sitting empty in my office. The itch to try saltwater had been growing, but the complexity seemed overwhelming. Sumps, protein skimmers, reef-ready tanks - where do you even start? And more importantly, how do you do it on a budget?

Enter Claude Desktop - not for coding this time, but for something completely different: planning a reef tank conversion.

The Conversation That Saved Me $1000+

My journey started with a simple question to Claude:

"I have a 75 gallon aquarium I previously use for freshwater, can it be used for salt water even though it doesn't have a sump?"

What followed was an incredibly detailed consultation that felt like having a reef expert in my office. Claude didn't just say "yes" - it explained the pros and cons, alternative equipment options, and specific challenges I'd face without a sump.

From General Advice to Specific Shopping Lists

When I asked for a specific Amazon shopping list, Claude got granular. After confirming my tank dimensions (48" x 18" x 21") and establishing my constraints:

  • Budget: Under $1000
  • Goals: Both fish and corals
  • Location: Office (noise not a major concern)

Claude launched into research mode, analyzing 284 sources over 5 minutes and 28 seconds. The result? A complete equipment guide with:

  • Prioritized recommendations within budget
  • Two complete system configurations ($995 balanced vs $750 budget-friendly)
  • Specific Amazon product links with current pricing and over 1,670 verified reviews
  • Scientific explanations (like why 445nm/460nm blue wavelengths are critical for coral photosynthesis)
  • Practical placement tips (wavemakers at opposite ends creating gyre patterns)

The $600 Question That Changed Everything

Before pulling the trigger, I had a moment of doubt: "For that price point should I start with a new tank that is built for salt water or use my existing tank?"

Claude's response was eye-opening. It broke down exactly what "reef-ready" tanks offer and whether I needed those features:

What I'd Get with a New Tank:

  • Built-in overflow and drilling ($600-1200)
  • Black background and overflow box
  • "Reinforced" glass (mostly marketing)

What I'd Save by Using My Existing Tank:

  • $600-1200 in tank costs
  • Money that could go toward:
    • Better protein skimmer
    • Quality RO/DI system
    • More live rock
    • Initial livestock
    • Test kits and supplies

Claude even reminded me to check for copper medication residue from freshwater days (toxic to invertebrates) and inspect the silicone seals - practical advice I wouldn't have thought of.

The AI Difference: Research + Context + Practicality

What struck me wasn't just the depth of knowledge, but how Claude contextualized everything for my specific situation:

  1. Budget-Aware Recommendations: Not just "here's the best equipment" but "here's what makes sense for your $1000 budget"

  2. Experience-Based Prioritization: Understanding that as a beginner, I needed forgiving equipment choices, not the cutting-edge gear

  3. Long-Term Thinking: Suggestions that would grow with the hobby, not require immediate replacement

  4. Real-World Practicality: Like suggesting two smaller heaters for redundancy, or explaining why HOB equipment visibility matters less than functionality at my budget

The Document That Became My Blueprint

Claude generated a comprehensive equipment guide that became my reef tank bible. The specificity was incredible:

The $995 Balanced Setup Claude Recommended:

  • Reef Octopus BH-100 Skimmer ($250) - Specifically designed for 75-gallon tanks
  • NICREW 48W Saltwater Light ($170) - Full spectrum with 445nm/460nm blues for coral photosynthesis
  • 2x FREESEA 1600 GPH Wavemakers ($150) - Creating the 20-40x turnover rate for mixed reefs
  • 2x Fluval M 150W Heaters ($80) - Redundancy to prevent temperature crashes
  • Instant Ocean Reef Crystals 160-gal ($70) - Enhanced calcium for coral growth
  • Testing & Auto Top-Off ($110) - Including a refractometer and DIGITEN smart ATO
  • CaribSea Aragonite & Rock ($129) - 80 lbs sand and 40 lbs base rock
  • Zilla Screen Cover ($36) - Perfect fit for 48" x 18" dimensions

Total: $995 - literally $5 under budget with every essential covered.

Claude even provided a budget alternative at $750 if I wanted to leave room for livestock, explaining exactly what trade-offs each substitution would involve.

This wasn't a generic "how to start a reef tank" guide - it was tailored specifically to:

  • My existing 75-gallon tank (48" x 18" x 21")
  • My exact $1000 budget constraint
  • My mixed reef goals (fish AND corals)
  • My office environment (recommending quiet equipment)

Beyond Code: AI as a Domain Expert

This experience showed me something powerful about AI assistants like Claude: they're not just for coding. When given the right context and allowed to research thoroughly, they can serve as knowledgeable consultants in almost any domain.

The key was in the interaction pattern:

  1. Start with the general question
  2. Provide specific constraints and context
  3. Ask for concrete, actionable outputs
  4. Challenge assumptions ("should I just buy new?")
  5. Let the AI research when needed

The Results

Thanks to Claude's guidance:

  • I saved $600+ by keeping my existing tank
  • Got a curated equipment list within budget
  • Avoided common beginner mistakes
  • Had confidence in my purchases knowing the reasoning behind each recommendation

The tank is now cycling, and I'm following the exact equipment list Claude provided. Every piece has performed as expected, and I'm well within budget with room for initial livestock.

What This Means for AI-Assisted Planning

This aquarium project demonstrated that AI assistants like Claude can be valuable for much more than code:

  • Research aggregation: 284 sources synthesized in minutes
  • Budget optimization: Balancing cost vs. quality with clear trade-offs
  • Domain expertise: Detailed knowledge about niche topics
  • Personalized recommendations: Not generic advice, but situation-specific guidance

Whether you're planning an aquarium, designing a home network, or choosing photography equipment, the pattern is the same: provide context, ask specific questions, and let the AI do the heavy lifting of research and synthesis.

The Unexpected Benefit

The most surprising outcome? The confidence it gave me. Reef keeping has a reputation for being complex and unforgiving. Having a detailed plan with reasoning behind every decision transformed it from intimidating to exciting.

I went from "maybe I should just stick to freshwater" to "I can do this" - all from a conversation with an AI that had never seen my tank but understood exactly what I needed.

Next time you're facing a complex project outside your expertise, consider having a conversation with Claude Desktop. You might be surprised how much a good AI consultant can help - even when the project has nothing to do with code.